Then & Now
John: During this viewing, I was beginning to wonder if Carolyn was going to be the third to throw herself over the cliff at Widow's Hill.
Christine: With the legend of either a third person or a governess falling from the cliff at Widows' Hill, you'd think Carolyn and Vicki would know better than to traipse around the cliff in the dark, especially when they got close enough to look over the edge and see a waterlogged corpse below. It was surprising to hear that Carolyn was allowed to run around the cliff when she was a kid. It makes me wonder how only two people have fallen (or thrown themselves) from the cliff, as the legend goes.
John: Let's review. Roger arrives home, and very shortly thereafter, Bill's body is discovered at the base of Widow's Hill.
Though I already knew Bill's fate on this go-around, before this week it seemed like he was destined for a lengthy tenure in Collinwood. The culmination of the first 50 episodes remains a high point of the pre-Barnabas era.
Christine: Our first corpse. Such a momentous occasion.
Shadows on the Wall
John: Interesting to see Carolyn actually playing the piano. So often they shoot someone behind the piano so they only have to mime the act of playing. Even more surprising is that she's not that great of a piano player.
Do you think Bil Baird created the floating Bill Malloy doll?
Christine: I don't think the show could afford the talents of Bil Baird at this point in the show just for a soaked dummy.
I love how quickly Roger abandoned his cold chicken sandwich and glass of milk in favor of the brandy as soon as Liz asked about his late-evening argument with Bill Malloy. However, it is concerning that he didn't seem to pour anything and appeared to be drinking from an empty glass. That is suspicious behavior indeed.
A few more things worth noticing…































































