Christine: Why is Elizabeth defending Matthew? What he did was wrong, no matter his intention, and he should be fired.
John: Carolyn seems more upset about Bill than Liz. She tells Vicki he was the nicest, sweetest man she's ever known. More than Joe? And Burke? And her uncle Roger?
Christine: Why would Roger meet Sam at the Blue Whale and openly discuss getting their stories straight? The Sheriff could probably expedite his inquiry if he questioned Bartender Bob Rooney.
John: As you pointed out 10 years ago, that shot in the Blue Whale with the reflection of the shimmering water remains a standout.
Shadows on the Wall
John: I don't know if Roger was attempting to go incognito, but if he sports another hat later on, a hat tracker will be in order. And they'll need a hat rack along with the coat rack.
Christine: Looking closely at the binding on the Family History Book, it's hard to make out the title written there, but could it be "The Holy and the Damned," as Carolyn calls it?
What interesting details caught your eye in this episode?
John: Sam asks Maggie if Burke had been to the diner, which makes sense given he's staying at the hotel; but when he asks about Roger, does he really think Roger is a frequent customer?
Roger thought it was proven that Bill drowned — who needs a pesky body. Stop acting so suspicious, Collins!
Roger was a jerk to suggest to Liz that she may be responsible for Bill's death. Fortunately, she dismissed that outright.
I love how the Sheriff just drops word that Bill Malloy is dead as he's walking out of the diner. Not exactly CSI, Collinsport.
Christine: Yeah, that was not only unprofessional from a law enforcement standpoint, but pretty callous to mention it so offhandedly to people who were close to him and would be upset to hear that sad news.
The Sheriff claims to know everyone in town quite well, saying he knows some people a great deal better than they like to think, but I still wonder how he knows Mrs. Johnson is a teetotaler.
Shadows on the Wall
John: Roger does manage to get some good drinking done, once the word is out that Bill is dead.
You pointed out ten years ago Sam smoking. I don't recall that being a common occurrence on the show, so probably no need to start a smoke tracker!
That said, we may need a Burke Devlin mayo tracker. According to Maggie, he wants lots and lots on his food.
Christine: It's funny how we don't always notice the smoking, but there is quite a lot of it on the show, and a tracker may be warranted. Someone has already created a wonderful compilation of smoking scenes, though it only covers the first 200 or so episodes.
Burke Devlin's condiment preferences may not be sufficient for a tracker, but they are definitely notable. It is interesting that he prefers butter and mustard on his ham and cheese sandwich (hold the lettuce), but wants lots of mayo on whatever he was ordering with his coffee in this episode. Unless he is just ordering lots of mayo and coffee, which would be truly disturbing.
The phone booth at the Collinsport Inn has apparently been relocated, giving us a completely different view from it. I wonder what prompted the change.
Here are some views from the phone booth in past episodes to compare. Now that I've inadvertently created a phone booth tracker, I notice that its location has been shifting slightly throughout its history.
